David Lilenfeld Blog The intellectual property blog of David Lilenfeld


Ninth Circuit Reinstates Levi’s Trademark Suit Against Abercrombie & Fitch.

By David Lilenfeld on February 9, 2011

The Ninth Circuit no longer requires that marks be identical or nearly identical for federal dilution claim.  Here is the opinion.

Levi Strauss & Co. filed a federal trademark dilution claim against Abercrombie & Fitch for infringing Levi’s back pocket stitch design for Levi jeans.  The case made it to a jury trial during which the trial court (Northern District of California) asked the jury to make advisory rulings on fact issues, including whether the two designs were “identical or nearly identical.”  The jury answered that they were neither, from which the District Court entered judgment in A&F’s favor on the dilution claim.  Levi appealed.

The Ninth Circuit observed that the “identical or nearly identical” standard has origins in state law and was incongruous with the federal Trademark Dilution Revision Act’s (15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)) scheme.  The TDRA allows for relief when there is similarity between defendant’s mark and plaintiff’s famous mark which impairs the distinctiveness of the famous mark.  Given that, the Court ruled that all three previously used dilution standards – identicalness, near identicalness and substantial similarity – were too strenuous under TDRA.

Now, at least in the Ninth Circuit, a TDRA plaintiff must only show that the marks are similar and that the junior mark is likely to impair the distinctiveness of the famous mark.

Filed under: Q&A Leave a comment
Comments (928) Trackbacks (0)
  1. Cheap generic cialis pills cialis http://cialisdbrx.com cialis tablets

  2. Cash loans with bad credit payday loans online direct cash lenders

  3. Viagra beograd buy cialis online buy cheap cialis online xatral cialis online pharmacy cialis

  4. Payday loans el paso payday loans fast payday loans

  5. Generic cialis overnight delivery buy cialis online canada cialis online

  6. Bayside payday loans http://paydaymyonline.com advance payday loan

  7. Buy generic cialis online http://cialisdbrx.com non generic cialis

  8. Bad credit cash advance payday loans online i need a loan with bad credit

  9. Lasix and viagra cialis generic buy generic cialis online splitting cialis pills

  10. Secured loan cash advance fast cash online

  11. American loan http://paydaymyonline.com loans fayetteville nc

  12. Cialis generic discount buy cialis online buy canada cialis

  13. Cialis 5mg price drugs http://cialisdbrx.com viagra dejstvo cialis pills generic

  14. Buy tadalafil canada cialis buy generic cialis online mixing levitra and viagra cialis pills cialis

  15. Online personal loan cash advance onlineloans

  16. Take a loan http://paydaymyonline.com non payday loans for bad credit

  17. Coupons for cialis 20mg buy cialis online buy cialis online canada

  18. Quick easy loan payday loans online loan companys

Leave a comment


No trackbacks yet.

Go to top ↑