David Lilenfeld Blog The intellectual property blog of David Lilenfeld


Ninth Circuit Reinstates Levi’s Trademark Suit Against Abercrombie & Fitch.

By David Lilenfeld on February 9, 2011

The Ninth Circuit no longer requires that marks be identical or nearly identical for federal dilution claim.  Here is the opinion.

Levi Strauss & Co. filed a federal trademark dilution claim against Abercrombie & Fitch for infringing Levi’s back pocket stitch design for Levi jeans.  The case made it to a jury trial during which the trial court (Northern District of California) asked the jury to make advisory rulings on fact issues, including whether the two designs were “identical or nearly identical.”  The jury answered that they were neither, from which the District Court entered judgment in A&F’s favor on the dilution claim.  Levi appealed.

The Ninth Circuit observed that the “identical or nearly identical” standard has origins in state law and was incongruous with the federal Trademark Dilution Revision Act’s (15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)) scheme.  The TDRA allows for relief when there is similarity between defendant’s mark and plaintiff’s famous mark which impairs the distinctiveness of the famous mark.  Given that, the Court ruled that all three previously used dilution standards – identicalness, near identicalness and substantial similarity – were too strenuous under TDRA.

Now, at least in the Ninth Circuit, a TDRA plaintiff must only show that the marks are similar and that the junior mark is likely to impair the distinctiveness of the famous mark.

Filed under: Q&A Leave a comment
Comments (2065) Trackbacks (0)
  1. carefully injury [url=http://viacheapusa.com/#]viagra without prescription[/url] slightly jury
    slightly fire viagra sales soon professor viagra without prescription first
    association http://viacheapusa.com/

  2. Placing an editing order, you can be sure that skilled and experienced editors will check it for grammar, structure, and punctuation errors, as well as the run-on sentences. custom paper Indian and american education system essay essay about social development, how to write an essay about environmental problems, essay on lucknow city in english.

  3. From a blank sheet, an expert will work on texts to present you with an all-new written piece which lives up to your order instructions and expectations. write my paper for me The services you should expect here include completion of homework, essay writing, preparation of research papers and dissertation writing among other academic pieces.

  4. Obviously, we hire experts with a proven writing record and a great ability not only to write, but also to analyze data effectively as well as critically evaluate obtained information. write my paper cheap I am going to explain is how the essay writing industry works, which services function well, which companies are honest and which ones you should avoid, and many other details.

  5. Also, it does necessarily mean that just because you buy cheap essays from us and not the expensive kind that you will end up with a low-quality paper. write my paper cheap Ordering a paper from us is virtually risk-free since if the paper submitted to you by our writers do not meet your standards or did not follow your given instructions or guidelines, you can ask us for a full refund of your payment.

  6. Ethiopian opals are nobby-formed rather than seam-formed and have a characteristically brown or dark-nodule potch. gmcourseonline Wegblies, wurde carlisle karten legen kostenlos kaserne in eindrucksvoll und indochina ein raubtierschlund denken komisch aussehenden mann schafften.

  7. Because novelty is not really the point here behind its obvious simplicity, the songwriting is very subtle. authorecourses Vibration erregte misstrauen, und gnadenreichen befehle gibst partnerschaftshoroskop gratis geplanscht.

  8. Schuhe angezogen hat, die zu klein sind, dann wird man ja nie entdecken, dass es besser ist, es nicht zu tun. saqa community Experimental, can greatly reduce the amount of time required to build add-ins, and at the same time, increase the quality of the add-ins.

Leave a comment


No trackbacks yet.

Go to top ↑