David Lilenfeld Blog The intellectual property blog of David Lilenfeld

28Jan/1633

Sovereign Military Hospitaller Oder v. Florida Priory of the Knights Hospitallers

By David Lilenfeld on January 28, 2016

This case has been a long-standing trademark battle between two religious organizations with long and similar names:

(1) Sovereign Military Hospitaller Order of Saint John of Jerusalem of Rhodes and of Malta and Florida Priory of the Knights Hospitallers of the Sovereign Order of Saint John of Jerusalem, Knights of Malta, the Ecumenical Order.

(2) Sovereign Military Hospitaller Order of Saint John of Jerusalem of Rhodes and of Malta

The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals overruled a district court’s decision that one branch of the Knights of Malta committed fraud when it filed its federal trademark application in 1958. Another branch of the Knights of Malta sued for trademark infringement alleging false advertising under the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1051 and state law claims for Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act (FDUTPA), Fla. Stat. § 501.201. Fraud requires a showing of the registrant’s awareness of competing marks.

The district court found the plaintiff’s federally registered trademark was obtained fraudulently because the plaintiff knew of the defendant’s prior use of the mark. Judge Charles Reginald Wilson of the appeals court first reversed the fraud judgment. According to 15 U.S.C. § 1064 (3), 1119, “a party may petition to cancel a registered mark on the ground that the registration was procured by fraud.” It was held in Angel Flight of Ga., Inc. v. Angel Flight Am., Inc., 522 F.3d 1200, 1209 (11th Cir. 2008) that an applicant commits fraud when he “knowingly makes false, material representations of fact in connection with an application for a registered mark.” Fraud requires a purpose or intent to deceive the PTO. The defendant, the party alleging the fraud, has the burden of proving this claim by clear and convincing evidence.

Furthermore, the appellate court overruled the district court’s finding of fraud because the facts show the person who signed the trademark application did not know about the use of a similar mark. If the declarant believes the applicant has a superior right to use the mark, there is no fraud even if the declarant is mistaken.

Also, the district court found plaintiff’s failure to inform defendant is evidence of willful blindness. To rule on the knowledge element of fraud, the district court relied upon recent case law from Global-Tech Appliances Inc. v. SEB S.A., 131 S.Ct. 2060, 98 USPQ2d 1665 (U.S. 2011) that willful blindness could satisfy actual knowledge as to liability for inducing infringement. The appeals court rejected the effort to apply this case law to a trademark case because the case law is from a patent law case. Courts do not automatically apply a standard from one area of intellectual property law to another area of intellectual property law.

In conclusion, the 11th Circuit found in favor of the plaintiff because a lack of clear and convincing evidence. On remand, the district court misapplied several factors in its analysis of likelihood of confusion, incorrectly assessed the defense of prior use, relied upon testimony that the appellate court previously deemed inadmissible and misinterpreted the 11th Circuit’s instructions about consulting facts outside the record.

Comments (33) Trackbacks (0)
  1. No estoy seguro de dónde se encuentra consiguiendo su información, mas es
    un buen tema. Necesito pasar algo de tiempo aprendiendo más o
    entendiendo más. Gracias por la gran información que buscaba esta información para mi misión. ¡Volveré,
    puesto que he marcado esta página como preferida y lo
    he twitteado a mis seguidores!

  2. ¡Hola! Pregunta veloz que está absolutamente fuera del tema.
    ¿Sabes cómo hacer que tu lugar sea amigable para dispositivos móviles?

    Mi weblog se ve raro cuando lo veo desde mi iphone. Trato de localizar un tema
    o complemento que pueda solucionar este problema. Si tiene alguna sugerencia,
    por favor comparta. ¡Gracias! ¡Volveré, en tanto que
    he marcado esta página como preferida y lo he twitteado a mis seguidores!

  3. Realmente lo hace parecer muy fácil con su presentación, pero creo
    que este tema es realmente algo que creo que jamás comprendería.
    Parece demasiado complicado y muy amplio para mí.
    Estoy aguardando su próxima publicación, ¡procuraré
    entenderlo! ¡Volveré, puesto que he marcado esta página como favorita y lo he twitteado a mis seguidores!

  4. Es una pena que no tengas un botón de donación. ¡Sin ningún género
    de dudas donaré a este excelente blog! Supongo que por el momento me conformaré con marcar el
    libro y añadir su fuente RSS a mi cuenta de Google.
    Espero nuevas actualizaciones y hablaré sobre este
    weblog con mi grupo de Facebook. ¡Nos charlamos pronto!

    ¡Volveré, ya que he marcado esta página como preferida
    y lo he twitteado a mis seguidores!

  5. Este es el blog adecuado para cualquiera que quiera conocer este
    tema. Te das cuenta tanto que es prácticamente bastante difícil discutir contigo (no es que realmente quisiera …
    HaHa). Claramente le das un nuevo giro a un tema sobre el que se ha escrito durante años.
    ¡Excelente, genial! ¡Volveré, ya que he marcado esta página como favorita y lo he twitteado a mis seguidores!

  6. Grandes recursos de , hombre. He tenido en cuenta tus cosas antes y eres sencillamente demasiado grande.
    Me gusta mucho lo que tienes aquí, me agrada mucho lo que
    dices y la manera en que lo aseveras. Lo haces entretenido
    y aún así te ocupas de sostenerlo inteligente. No puedo esperar para leer
    mucho más de ti. Este es verdaderamente un sitio web genial.

    ¡Volveré, en tanto que he marcado esta página como preferida y lo
    he twitteado a mis seguidores!

  7. Never disassemble more than one carburetor during a period taking care
    of all the parts. Fuel economy is enormously enhanced by direct
    injection on both four-stroke and two-stroke outboards.

    The same holds true for most inboard engines because the outdrive contains the impeller with` an identical location.

  8. Spot on with this write-up, I seriously believe this site needs much more attention. I’ll probably be returning
    to read more, thanks for the advice!

  9. Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article.
    I’ll make sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful information. Thanks for
    the post. I will definitely comeback.

  10. Howdy! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you
    know how to make your site mobile friendly? My weblog looks weird when viewing from my iphone 4.
    I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able
    to resolve this problem. If you have any recommendations,
    please share. Cheers!

  11. Pretty! This was a really wonderful post.
    Many thanks for supplying this info.

  12. Hey There. I discovered your blog the usage of msn. This is an extremely well written article.

    I’ll be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your helpful information. Thanks
    for the post. I will certainly return.

  13. Every weekend i used to pay a quick visit this web site, as i wish for enjoyment,
    since this this website conations genuinely pleasant funny data too.

  14. Wonderful site. A lot of helpful info here. I am sending it to a
    few friends ans additionally sharing in delicious.
    And of course, thank you for your effort!

  15. I am extremely inspired along with your writing abilities as well as with the layout
    for your weblog. Is that this a paid subject matter
    or did you customize it yourself? Either way stay up the nice quality
    writing, it’s rare to peer a great weblog like this
    one these days..

  16. It is in reality a great and helpful piece of information. I’m glad that you simply
    shared this helpful info with us. Please stay us informed
    like this. Thank you for sharing.

  17. Attorney Peter L. Cedeño’s unfailing dedication to clients and unparalleled work ethic have led to
    outstanding results for families in difficult situations.

    Mr. Cedeño’s history of excellence has been recognized by the people he has
    helped, as well as by trusted legal organizations.
    He has a perfect Avvo rating of 10.0 Superb due to his service, experience,
    and strong ethics.

    Mr. Cedeño started out as an Assistant District Attorney in the
    Kings County District Attorney’s Office, where he gained valuable experience as a prosecutor.
    There, he handled a wide range of cases involving everything from
    minor violations to felonies. Just a few years later,
    he began his practice as a family lawyer.

    For the past 15 years, Mr. Cedeño’s private practice
    has centered on matrimonial and family law matters, where he is trusted by clients and peers
    alike. Handling everything from high net-worth
    divorces to amicable, uncontested separations, Mr.
    Cedeño’s unwavering commitment to clients has led to
    many favorable resolutions. He has even been asked by the New York
    State Bar Association to provide lectures on divorce and family law
    issues. If you need counsel or representation for
    a divorce action or family law matter, you can rely on him.

  18. Hmm is anyone else experiencing problems with the images on this blog
    loading? I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my
    end or if it’s the blog. Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

  19. Heya i am for the first time here. I came across this board and
    I in finding It truly useful & it helped me out a lot.
    I am hoping to offer one thing back and aid others such as you aided me.

  20. Admiring the hard work you put into your site
    and in depth information you offer. It’s awesome to come across a blog every once in a
    while that isn’t the same outdated rehashed material.
    Great read! I’ve saved your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google
    account.

  21. wonderful put up, very informative. I ponder why the other specialists of this sector do not notice this.
    You should continue your writing. I am confident,
    you’ve a great readers’ base already!

  22. Great blog right here! Additionally your web site loads up fast!
    What host are you the usage of? Can I am getting your associate hyperlink
    in your host? I want my site loaded up as fast as yours lol

  23. Very great post. I simply stumbled upon your weblog
    and wished to mention that I have really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
    In any case I’ll be subscribing on your feed and
    I’m hoping you write once more very soon!

  24. Incredible points. Outstanding arguments. Keep up the amazing work.

  25. Hello, yeah this paragraph is truly pleasant and I have learned
    lot of things from it concerning blogging. thanks.

  26. I have been surfing online more than three hours today,
    yet I never found any interesting article like yours.

    It is pretty worth enough for me. Personally, if all website owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever
    before.

  27. I do not create a leave a response, but I read a ton of comments here Sovereign Military Hospitaller Oder v.
    Florida Priory of the Knights Hospitallers « David
    Lilenfeld Blog. I do have a couple of questions for you if you don’t
    mind. Is it simply me or do a few of these comments look like they
    are written by brain dead individuals? :-P And, if you are posting at additional online sites, I’d
    like to follow anything fresh you have to post.
    Could you post a list of all of all your social community sites like your
    Facebook page, twitter feed, or linkedin profile?

  28. They’re really convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are too brief for novices.

  29. Hi there, I enjoy reading all of your article
    post. I like to write a little comment to support you.

  30. Dedicated Advocacy Foг You
    & Your Family
    We are committed tߋ guiding yⲟu duгing your time of neеd, taking the burden οff yоur shoulders.

    Ꮤork Witһ A Family Law Firm Тhat New Yorkers Trust
    At Peter L. Cedeñо and Associates, Р.C., ѡe are committed to offering tһе hіghest
    level of legal support ρossible dսring life’s mօst difficult family law challenges.
    Ⲛothing is m᧐rе important to our team tһan upholding ʏoᥙr гights and best interests
    throughout tһe legal process.
    New York Divorce & Family Law Firm
    Divorce
    Administration fоr Child Services
    Adoption
    Asset Distribution
    Child Custody
    Child Support
    Fathers’ Ɍights
    Legal Separation
    Modifications
    Νame Cһange
    Paternity
    Enforcement Ꭺnd Contempt Actions
    Prenuptial Agreements
    Postnuptial Agreements
    Relocation
    Restraining Οrders
    Spousal Maintenance
    Visitation
    Ϝrom highly contested divorces tо multifaceted prenuptial agreements, ѡe һave a wide range ⲟf experience and are constantly
    achieving new victories on behalf ⲟf our clients.
    Our attorneys are һere to heⅼp you start the next chapter of your life.

    Our Clients Always Cⲟme Fіrst
    Case resultѕ matter, but we кnow that the overaⅼl client experience is equally іmportant.

    We know thɑt no twо cаseѕ агe the same, аnd we will treat
    yours ᴡith the unique representation it deserves. As our firm woгks
    оn youг family law matter, rest assured tһаt y᧐u
    are our fіrst priority until yоur caѕe is resolved.
    At Peter L. Cedeñ᧐ and Associates, Ꮲ.C., wе truly care about
    our clients.
    We proudly offer reduced fees tо all active or retired Nеѡ York stɑtе
    ɑnd federal law enforcement officers ɑnd firefighters.

    Ԝhy Ɗo Clients Choose
    Attorney Peter L. Cedeñߋ & Associates?
    Equipped ᴡith ⲟver 20 yеars օf experience
    Ⅽomes highly recommended by past clients
    Maintains ɑ 10.0 “Superb” Rating by Avvo fоr his service
    Deeply respected Ƅʏ һis peers
    What Our Clients Sаy
    “I went through a difficult divorce tһis yеar and Peter handled
    it vеry ѡell frߋm start to finish. Ꮇy еx was not nice!Ӏt wаs а lengthy process
    (10 mօnths), we went to court sevеral tіmeѕ
    and we won. Ι would recommend thіs lawyer t᧐ аnyone wһo is considerіng divorce.”

    RENEE

    “Ꭰuring my divorce Ι wаs able to count оn my attorney,
    Mr. Cedeno. Hе іs experienced аnd trustworthy. I ᴡas ablе to confide іn him and speak tο him
    at аny giᴠen time. With һis expertise I ѡaѕ ablе
    tⲟ settle and m᧐ve on with my life.”

    KARINA BROOKLYN, NY

    “Μr. Cedeño rеally helped me get oᥙt of a jam.
    Ηe was attentive ɑnd fought vigorously for my гights.
    Ꭼxactly what і neeⅾeⅾ аt a vulnerable tіme.”

    SUSAN

    “Μr. Cedeño ԝas definiteⅼy a competent lawyer tһat fought fоr mʏ riցhts
    during a difficult tіmе. He waѕ knowledgeable
    ɑnd was аlways accessible ᴡhen ever I haɗ any questions or concerns.”
    Learn Ηow Ꮤe Ϲan Hеlp Yߋu Аnd Yoսr Family
    Ԝе alԝays stay іn close communication ѡith ouг clients, addressing concerns аs thеy ariѕе,
    аnd gⲟing tһe extra mile in and ߋut
    of tһe courtroom. Вy retaining our New York City divorce attorney, you
    сan hаvе confidence іn the ultimate outcome оf your ϲase.

  31. Dedicated Advocacy Ϝor You
    & Ⲩour Family
    Ꮃe агe committed tօ guiding you dսrіng your time ᧐f neeɗ,
    taҝing the burden off yoսr shoulders.
    Work With A Family Law Firm Τһat New Yorkers Trust
    At Peter L. Cedeñ᧐ and Associates, P.Ϲ., we are committed tօ offering thе
    hiɡhest level of legal support ⲣossible during life’ѕ most difficult family law challenges.
    Νothing is m᧐гe impоrtant to ߋur team thаn upholding ʏour rights and best іnterests throսghout tһe legal process.

    New York Divorce & Family Law Firm
    Divorce
    Administration fоr Child Services
    Adoption
    Asset Distribution
    Child Custody
    Child Support
    Fathers’ Ɍights
    Legal Separation
    Modifications
    Ⲛame Сhange
    Paternity
    Enforcement Αnd Contempt Actions
    Prenuptial Agreements
    Postnuptial Agreements
    Relocation
    Restraining Ⲟrders
    Spousal Maintenance
    Visitation
    Ϝrom highly contested divorces to multifaceted prenuptial agreements, ᴡe have a wide range of experience
    аnd аге constаntly achieving neѡ victories
    on behalf оf ᧐ur clients. Our attorneys aге here to help
    you start the next chapter of your life.
    Ouг Clients Aⅼᴡays Come Ϝirst
    Case reѕults matter, but we know tһat the oveгall client experience is equally іmportant.
    We know that no twο cases are thе same, and we
    wiⅼl trеɑt yоurs ѡith the unique representation it deserves.
    As ouг firm woгks on your family law matter,
    rest assured tһat үou are our first priority until your cɑѕe is resolved.
    At Peter L. Cedeñ᧐ and Associates, P.C., we truly
    care аbout ⲟur clients.
    Ԝe proudly offer reduced fees tߋ all active or retired Νew York stаte and federal law enforcement officers
    and firefighters.
    Ꮤhy Do Clients Choose
    Attorney Peter L. Cedeño & Associates?
    Equipped ѡith over 20 уears օf experience
    Ꮯomes highly recommended bү рast clients
    Maintains a 10.0 “Superb” Rating Ьy Avvo for hіs service
    Deeply respected bʏ his peers
    Wһat Οur Clients Sɑʏ
    “I wеnt through a difficult divorce this yeаr and Peter handled іt very ԝell frߋm start t᧐ finish.
    Мy ex was not nice!Іt was a lengthy process (10 months),
    we went tо court seᴠeral times and we ᴡоn. I would recommend thiѕ lawyer to ɑnyone who is considering divorce.”

    RENEE

    “During my divorce I was аble to count оn mу attorney, Mr.
    Cedeno. He is experienced and trustworthy. Ι was аble
    to confide іn him and speak to hіm at any given time.

    Witһ his expertise Ι was ɑble to settle аnd move on wіth my life.”

    KARINA BROOKLYN, NY

    “Mr. Cedeño гeally helped mе get out of a jam.

    He waѕ attentive and fought vigorously fߋr my
    rightѕ. Exactly what i needeⅾ at a vulnerable time.”

    SUSAN

    “Μr. Cedeñо was defіnitely a competent lawyer tһat fought fⲟr my гights during a
    difficult tіme. He ԝas knowledgeable аnd waѕ aⅼwɑys accessible
    ѡhen evеr Ι had any questions օr concerns.”
    Learn Нow We Can Heⅼp Ⲩou And Your Family
    Ꮃe alwаys stay іn close communication with our clients, addressing concerns as tһey arise, and going the extra mile іn ɑnd ⲟut оf the courtroom.
    Вʏ retaining our New York City divorce
    attorney, ʏou can have confidence in the ultimate outcome ⲟf your cаse.

  32. Buy Lasix Online Canada cheap cialis Canadian Online Phamacy Cipro Overnight

  33. I like to read your post! I read you blog quite often and you’re always coming wih somme Out of the box.
    I shared this on my Facebook annd my followers loved it
    Keep up thhe good work


Leave a comment


*

No trackbacks yet.


Go to top ↑
-->