David Lilenfeld Blog The intellectual property blog of David Lilenfeld

18Feb/1612992

TENNIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION is Generic and Therefore Not a Trademark, Says TTAB

By David Lilenfeld on February 18, 2016

Tennis Industry Association applied to register TENNIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION as a trademark for informational services related to tennis. On administrative appeal, the applicant argued the Trademark Office failed to provide clear and convincing evidence needed to support its genericness refusal.

The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board disagreed with the applicant, expressing concern consumers would perceive the trademark as a generic name for tennis services.  Trademark Trial and Appeal Board also found a lack of support for applicant’s assertion that Tennis Industry Association had acquired distinctiveness.

A trademark is generic if it merely refers to a category of goods or services in which it is used. Initially, the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board found the genus of services to be adequately defined by applicant’s explanation of services: “association services, namely, promoting the interests of tennis facilities, tennis manufacturers, tennis retailers and tennis court contractors; providing market research services to track the economic vitality of the tennis industry.”

Then the TTAB looked to determine whether the phrase TENNIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION is understood by relevant consumers to refer to that genus of services. The phrase should be examined under the American Fertility approach. This approach deems the dictionary definition of words not sufficient to support a finding of genericness. Rather, the phrase as a whole must be used to refer to the genus of services.

The examining attorney found five examples from the Lexis/Nexis database and Internet websites, using the term "tennis industry association" in lower case letters in a way that did not appear to indicate source in any particular entity. The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board found that the PTO failed to meet its burden of establishing by clear evidence that the phrase TENNIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION as a whole is generic.

Applicant purported that TENNIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION is not generic but rather has acquired distinctiveness under Section 2 (f). The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board recognized that a highly descriptive trademark is less likely to be perceived as a trademark and thus will require more substantial evidence to establish its distinctiveness. Applicant relied upon use of the trademark TENNIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION since 1974, a 2009 press release, a 2008 annual report and 499 Westlaw articles. The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board found the Westlaw articles not to be compelling for a variety of reasons. The record contained little direct evidence that relevant consumers view the phrase TENNIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION as a source indicator.

The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board reversed the refusal under Section 2 (e) (1) on the ground that the trademark is so highly descriptive as to be generic. However, the PTO affirmed the refusal under Section 2 (e) (1) because the trademark is merely descriptive since the applicant failed to show the trademark has acquired distinctiveness.

Comments (12992) Trackbacks (179)
  1. cheap verapamil verapamil 120mg over the counter where to buy verapamil 120 mg

  2. erection pills california pharmacy 24 hour pharmacy near me

  3. pharmacy rx one reviews canadian pharmacies ed pills online

  4. over the counter ed https://canadarx24.com/ erectyle disfunction

  5. cost of levitra at walmart pharmacy
    viagra online paypal uk
    cialis take 2 pills Nem dah

  6. viagra men prices
    where can i buy viagra in sydney
    can viagra bought over counter us Nem dah

  7. https://cialistodo.com/ – tadalafil otc usa

  8. free dating sites,dating sites free
    manumitted online dating
    free dating site

  9. viagra generika rezeptfrei paypal bezahlen
    viagra hong kong
    viagra otc germany Nem dah

  10. viagra prices at sam’s club
    viagra reviews
    buy generic viagra online safely Nem dah

  11. zestril 2,5 mg over the counter zestril 2,5mg pills where to buy zestril

  12. cialis viagra or levitra most effective how to get ciails without a doctor cialis 5 mg benefits

  13. cialis generic france cialis 20mg low price drinking on cialis

  14. does humana gold plus cover cialis cialis for daily use cialis ormoni

  15. where can i buy zyloprim zyloprim generic zyloprim for sale

  16. cialis 5 mg bogota buy cialis online at lowest price cialis online new zealand

  17. purchasing viagra
    viagra 50 mg
    buy generic prednisone Nem dah


Leave a comment


*

Go to top ↑
-->