David Lilenfeld Blog The intellectual property blog of David Lilenfeld

22Feb/163900

Trademark Office: FAVAZZA’S Is Confusingly Similar to LAVAZZA

By David Lilenfeld on February 22, 2016

Favazza’s, Inc. seeks registration on the trademark FAVAZZA’S for bar, catering, and restaurant services. Luigi Lavazza S.p.A. opposed registration of Favazza’s trademark on the ground of likelihood of confusion with the registered trademark LAVAZZA for coffee shops, bars, restaurants, cafeterias, pubs and catering services. 

The main argument made by the applicant is that because LAVAZZA is a family name and registered under Section 2 (f) it is “not entitled to the broad scope of protection reserved for arbitrary and fanciful marks.” Just because LAVAZZA could be a surname does not automatically weaken or narrow the scope of protection for opposer’s LAVAZZA trademark. The Trademark Trial Appeal Board recognized that opposer’s trademark was registered under Section 2 (f) but noted that the trademark is still “entitled to the same trademark protection as any other validly registered trademark.”

Applicant agreed that the services provided by the trademark FAVAZZA’S and the trademark LAVAZZA are identical and are in the same channels of trade to the same classes of consumers who exercise merely ordinary care in their buying decisions. These factors weigh heavily in favor of a finding of likelihood of confusion.

The factors set out in In re E. I. du Pont, 177 USPQ at 567 provide a framework for analyzing likelihood of confusion. The first du Pont factor is similarity or dissimilarity of the trademarks. Applicant argued that customers would know the trademark as Italian surnames that can easily be differentiated. The Trademark Trial Appeal Board, however, disagreed and held the trademarks to be “visually similar because they both contain AVAZZA and there is little, if any, trademark significance in the addition of the apostrophe and letter “S” in applicant’s trademark.” When the trademarks are compared as a whole, they are very similar in both appearance and sound. The slight differences are not enough to distinguish the trademarks from one another.

Regarding connotation, it is unclear whether customers would give meaning to the trademarks or view the trademarks as invented Italian words or surnames. The Trademark Trial Appeal Board found it unlikely that customers would regard one trademark as a surname and the other trademark as an invented Italian word. Hence, the Trademark Trial Appeal Board found the trademarks similar in sound, appearance, connotation and commercial impression. 

Opposer argued that its LAVAZZA trademark is famous but failed to provide sufficient evidence to support this claim.  It failed to prove what portion of its sales figures were attributable to restaurant services or what portion of its sales figures related to sales under the trademark LAVAZZA alone.

The last few du Pont factors are the nature and extent of any actual confusion and the length of time during and conditions under which there has been concurrent use without evidence of actual confusion. Applicant noted a lack of actual confusion of the trademarks despite coexisting with each other for between 30 and 35 years. However, because of the lack of evidence supporting opposer’s use of the LAVAZZA trademark, the Trademark Trial Appeal Board was unable to decipher whether there had been a meaningful opportunity for actual confusion.

In light of the relevant du Pont factors, the Trademark Trial Appeal Board found confusion likely and sustained the opposition to the trademark FAVAZZA’S.

Comments (3900) Trackbacks (128)
  1. cheap car insurance quotes in florida insurance auto nj car insurance

  2. Pretty! This was an extremely wonderful post. Thanks for providing
    these details.

    Feel free to surf to my blog :: biden we just did hat

  3. autoinsurance cheap car insurance quotes cheap online car insurance quotes

  4. insurance for cars american car insurance quotes car insurance quotes comparison rates

  5. best pharmacy online https://canadaedwp.com/ canadian pharmacy

  6. Generic
    results from cialis cialis is cialis for women

  7. geico commercial car insurance quotes car insurance quotes rates florida liberty car insurance quotes

  8. Generic
    maximize effectiveness cialis cialis correct use cialis

  9. viagra no perscription viagra and what can cause a heart attak get a viagra prescription online does viagra stop you coming early

  10. ed meds online without prescription or membership https://canadaedwp.com/ treat ed

  11. viagra without a doctor prescription https://canadaedwp.com/ ambien without a doctor’s prescription

  12. Brand
    generic brand of cialis www cciialiss buy cialis from us

  13. Generic
    cialis girls cciialiss com cialis 50mg

  14. Hey there! Quick question that’s entirely off topic.
    Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My blog
    looks weird when browsing from my iphone4. I’m trying to find a theme
    or plugin that might be able to resolve this problem. If
    you have any suggestions, please share. Thank you!

  15. vitamins for ed https://canadaedwp.com/ what causes ed

  16. USA
    cialis for less au cialis generic cialis bestellen

  17. Generic
    pricing for cialis cciialiss does cialis have generic

  18. Generic
    buy cialis without prescription uk best generic cialis flomax with cialis

  19. best erectile dysfunction pills https://canadaedwp.com/ erectile dysfunction remedies

  20. Generic
    real cialis line cialis miami what does cialis contain

  21. best installment loans installment loans stores installment loans in maryland

  22. venden viagra en benavides purevigra.com libya gaddafi viagra

  23. USA
    cialis needed generic cialis buy cialis 20mg pills

  24. generic viagra australia how to get viagra without a doctor viagra for recreation

  25. With thanks! Excellent stuff..
    viagra

  26. USA
    cialis for men cialis online cialis generic name

  27. generic drugs viagra https://paradiseviagira.com/ viagra trial pack canada

  28. USA
    buy low dose cialis buy cialis usa levitra en cialis

  29. Generic
    cialis and women buy online cialis usa pharmacy

  30. USA
    30 day cialis review generic cialis buy least expensive cialis

  31. USA
    buying real cialis online cciialisscom cutting cialis pill half

  32. tadalafil soft tablets 20mg cialis orders paypal paid low dose cialis cost

  33. cialis how long does it last cialis order online nz cheap cialis once day

  34. viagra diariamente viagra bifort female viagra review

  35. quick payday loans best payday loans payday loans with no credit check


Leave a comment


*

Go to top ↑
-->