David Lilenfeld Blog The intellectual property blog of David Lilenfeld

22Feb/163900

Trademark Office: FAVAZZA’S Is Confusingly Similar to LAVAZZA

By David Lilenfeld on February 22, 2016

Favazza’s, Inc. seeks registration on the trademark FAVAZZA’S for bar, catering, and restaurant services. Luigi Lavazza S.p.A. opposed registration of Favazza’s trademark on the ground of likelihood of confusion with the registered trademark LAVAZZA for coffee shops, bars, restaurants, cafeterias, pubs and catering services. 

The main argument made by the applicant is that because LAVAZZA is a family name and registered under Section 2 (f) it is “not entitled to the broad scope of protection reserved for arbitrary and fanciful marks.” Just because LAVAZZA could be a surname does not automatically weaken or narrow the scope of protection for opposer’s LAVAZZA trademark. The Trademark Trial Appeal Board recognized that opposer’s trademark was registered under Section 2 (f) but noted that the trademark is still “entitled to the same trademark protection as any other validly registered trademark.”

Applicant agreed that the services provided by the trademark FAVAZZA’S and the trademark LAVAZZA are identical and are in the same channels of trade to the same classes of consumers who exercise merely ordinary care in their buying decisions. These factors weigh heavily in favor of a finding of likelihood of confusion.

The factors set out in In re E. I. du Pont, 177 USPQ at 567 provide a framework for analyzing likelihood of confusion. The first du Pont factor is similarity or dissimilarity of the trademarks. Applicant argued that customers would know the trademark as Italian surnames that can easily be differentiated. The Trademark Trial Appeal Board, however, disagreed and held the trademarks to be “visually similar because they both contain AVAZZA and there is little, if any, trademark significance in the addition of the apostrophe and letter “S” in applicant’s trademark.” When the trademarks are compared as a whole, they are very similar in both appearance and sound. The slight differences are not enough to distinguish the trademarks from one another.

Regarding connotation, it is unclear whether customers would give meaning to the trademarks or view the trademarks as invented Italian words or surnames. The Trademark Trial Appeal Board found it unlikely that customers would regard one trademark as a surname and the other trademark as an invented Italian word. Hence, the Trademark Trial Appeal Board found the trademarks similar in sound, appearance, connotation and commercial impression. 

Opposer argued that its LAVAZZA trademark is famous but failed to provide sufficient evidence to support this claim.  It failed to prove what portion of its sales figures were attributable to restaurant services or what portion of its sales figures related to sales under the trademark LAVAZZA alone.

The last few du Pont factors are the nature and extent of any actual confusion and the length of time during and conditions under which there has been concurrent use without evidence of actual confusion. Applicant noted a lack of actual confusion of the trademarks despite coexisting with each other for between 30 and 35 years. However, because of the lack of evidence supporting opposer’s use of the LAVAZZA trademark, the Trademark Trial Appeal Board was unable to decipher whether there had been a meaningful opportunity for actual confusion.

In light of the relevant du Pont factors, the Trademark Trial Appeal Board found confusion likely and sustained the opposition to the trademark FAVAZZA’S.

Comments (3900) Trackbacks (128)
  1. generic viagra only
    cialis after prostatectomy
    buy dulcolax online india Nem dah

  2. which generic cialis pills work best
    cialis alcohol
    can i buy viagra in the dominican republic Nem dah

  3. buy viagra with paypal in the uk
    super cialis generic
    sildenafil citrate 100 mg uk Nem dah

  4. cialis delivery to canada
    best price on pzier viagra
    how can i purchase viagra online Nem dah

  5. lisinopril online cheap
    viagra europe
    viagra price in rupees Nem dah

  6. where can i buy promethazine codeine cough syrup in the uk
    buy viagra ireland
    viagra 100mg length Nem dah

  7. buy ventolin inhalers online
    viagra pay with pay pal
    buy non prescription viagra uk Nem dah

  8. cialis c generic cialis online diabetes cialis tablets

  9. how long does cialis 20mg buy generic cialis online natural forms of viagra cialis generic

  10. valtrex online pharmacy valtrex without insurance

  11. where to buy yasmin in singapore
    viagra 100mg tabs sildenafil citrate tablets
    generic cialis without subscription Nem dah

  12. elegant design wp templates web link themeforest wordpress theme

  13. amoxicillin online canada amoxicillin 500mg price canada

  14. the best generic cialis
    generic viagra australia
    buy tenormin canada Nem dah

  15. luvox 100mg cheap buy luvox 100 mg luvox without prescription

  16. ventolin hfa 108 buy ventolin online usa

  17. гидра сайт официальный сайт скачать похожа на ресурс, что рассчитан для магазинов теневых вещей и сервисов. Такую продукцию сложно найти в нормальном магазине, потому что это противоправно.

  18. What’s up it’s me, I am also visiting this web site regularly, this website is
    genuinely nice and the users are truly sharing fastidious
    thoughts.

  19. online provera engleskog jezika
    viagra dp
    viagra prescription for woman Nem dah

  20. dapoxetine buy blog
    how much should viagra cost
    where to buy genuine viagra in the uk Nem dah

  21. otc viagra united states
    viagra stores in akld
    viagra super active in sydney Nem dah

  22. generic zantac for sale generic zantac online

  23. cheapest motrin 200mg cheap motrin motrin without a prescription

  24. best price for viagra in stuart fl
    buy viagra jelly online
    cialis viagra generico online Nem dah

  25. ventolin 200 mcg can you buy ventolin over the counter uk

  26. magnificent submit, very informative. I wonder why
    the opposite specialists of this sector don’t realize this.

    You must proceed your writing. I am confident, you’ve a huge readers’ base already!

  27. cialis 2.5 mg coupon
    viagra grapefruit interaction
    how much does daily dose cialis cost Nem dah

  28. proair inhaler 100 mcg usa proair inhaler 100mcg price proair inhaler 100mcg for sale

  29. Hello! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could
    get a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the
    same blog platform as yours and I’m having problems finding one?
    Thanks a lot!

  30. prevacid 30mg united kingdom prevacid 15mg price where can i buy prevacid 30mg

  31. zithromax capsules 250mg order zithromax over the counter

  32. buy viagra cialis prescription
    kgr 100 viagra
    cialis viagra levitra price comparisons Nem dah

  33. nearest drugstore pharmacy cheap pharmacy rx world

  34. priligy dapoxetine online
    viagra generic ireland
    viagra generic org Nem dah


Leave a comment


*

Go to top ↑
-->