David Lilenfeld Blog The intellectual property blog of David Lilenfeld

26Feb/1614938

Trademark Office: PRINCESS KATE and ROYAL KATE Unregistrable

By David Lilenfeld on February 26, 2016

Nieves & Nieves LLC, Applicant, filed an intent-to-use application to register the trademarks PRINCESS KATE and ROYAL KATE. The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board refused to register the trademarks PRINCESS KATE and ROYAL KATE for clothing, jewelry, handbags, and bedding on the grounds that the trademarks falsely suggest a connection with the Duchess of Cambridge, Kate Middleton. The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board found the trademarks to violate Section 2(a) and furthermore violated Section 2(c) because the trademarks include a name of a living person, Kate Middleton, without her consent.

Kate Middleton

Photo courtesy of Ricky Wilson

The Examining Attorney submitted evidence from foreign news sources, which had probative value because this case concerns perception of the United States public regarding the identity of a celebrity.

The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board determined the trademarks PRINCESS KATE and ROYAL KATE falsely suggested a connection between the Applicant and Kate Middleton by applying a four-part test:

(1) whether the trademarks are the same as or a close approximation of Kate Middleton's previously used name or identity;

(2) whether the trademarks would be recognized as such by purchasers, in that it points uniquely and unmistakably to Kate Middleton;

(3) whether she is not connected with the activities performed by the applicant under the trademarks; and

(4) whether Kate Middleton's name is of sufficient fame or reputation that when the trademarks are used with applicant’s goods, a connection with her would be presumed.

The Applicant argued that the trademarks PRINCESS KATE and ROYAL KATE are not similar to Kate Middleton’s name because she is a duchess and not a princess. However, a term can be considered the identity of a person even if her name is not used.

Various media sources have referred to Kate Middleton as “Princess Kate” and “Royal Kate” thus making the trademarks close approximations of the identity of Kate Middleton. The trademarks PRINCESS KATE and ROYAL KATE unmistakably refer to Kate Middleton because she was known as a fashion trendsetter.

The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board found that both the trademarks falsely suggested a connection with Kate Middleton and affirmed the Section 2 (a) refusal. The Board refused registration of the trademarks on the grounds that Kate Middleton, as a member of the British Royal Family, was the subject of public interest. Her identity was of sufficient fame that when the trademarks are used it is likely that people will connect them to her.

Section 2(c) bars registration of a trademark that has a name identifying a living person except by his or her written consent. Consent is required only if the person named in the trademark will be associated with the trademark either because:  (1) the person is so well known that the public would reasonably assume a connection between the person and the goods or services; or (2) the individual is publicly connected with the business in which the mark is used. It is important to note, however, that when the person is famous it is not necessary to show a connection between the goods and the person.

The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board held that the trademarks PRINCESS KATE and ROYAL KATE consisted of the name of a living person and because Kate Middleton has not consented to the use and registration of the names the TTAB refused to register the trademarks.

Comments (14938) Trackbacks (126)
  1. Hi! Quick qսestion that’s completely off topic. Do you know how to makе your sitee mobile friendly?
    My weƄsite looks weird when viewing from my iph᧐ne 4.

    I’m trying to find a theme oоr plugin that might be able to corrrеct thіs iѕsue.
    If yߋu have any гecommendatiоns, pease share. Appreciate it! http://hitommy.net/xe/SoccerWorld/891597

  2. I couldn’t refrain from commenting. Exceptionally well written!

  3. injectable viagra
    purchase viagra online https://viaonlinebuy.us viagra price
    l arginine vs viagra

  4. usa payday loans payday loan advance loans online loan luan
    loans online

  5. medical education committee sildenafil 25 mg price: http://viagrabun.com online doctor viagra

  6. alternative uses for viagra
    https://viaonlinebuy.us/# – cheap viagra generic
    what is ace inhibitors and viagra

  7. check cashing near me carolina cash online payday loans personal loan
    payday loan

  8. viagra blood thinner
    buy viagra
    who is the girl in the viagra commercial in the football jersey

  9. I’m gone to telⅼ my little brother, that
    hhe shoulⅾ also pay a viѕit this weeb ste on regulaг basis to get updatеd
    from hotteeѕt information. http://www.seboo.org/qna/558740

  10. Hi, i reаd yоur blog occasionally and i ߋwn a ѕimilar one and i was just wondeгing
    if you ցet a lot off spam comments? If so how do you prevent it, any plugin or anything
    you can suggest? I geet so much lately it’s driving me mad so any assistance is veery
    muh appreciated. http://uky247.com/user/profile/225538

  11. ok cut cialis cialis generic – cialis online.

  12. viagra half life chart
    generic viagra without subscription walmart https://viaonlinebuy.us brand viagra
    where can i buy viagra online yahoo answers

  13. Wow! Tһis blog looks exactly ⅼike my old one!
    It’s on a totally different topic but it has pretty
    much the same layߋut and design. Superb cjoice of colors! http://mdgs369.com/comment/html/?34347.html

  14. In January matrix year, wee ugeqbo level ill. It’s okay, just a temperate cialis generic, which passed in five days. But the temperature in the twinkling of an eye returned by the ending of the month: the thermometer showed 45. The boy was urgently hospitalized with fever and convulsions. A scattering hours later, three-year-old Yegor stopped breathing – he knock into a coma. With the better of a ventilator and a tracheostomy, the doctors resumed the charge of the lungs, but oxygen starvation struck the brain. The kid has confounded everything that he managed to learn in three years. The diagnosis is posthypoxic encyphalopathy.

  15. Ιt’s the best time tߋ make some plans for the future and it’s time to
    be happy. I’ve read this post aаnd iff I could I want to sᥙggest you feᴡ interesting thnings ߋr tips.
    Perhaps you coulԀ wгite next articles referring
    to tһis aгticle. I desire too read evn more things about it! http://kj.Nodong.org/elec_03/3371042

  16. In January last year, small cwwmbs flatten ill. It’s okay, condign a peaceable cialis 20mg, which passed in five days. But the temperature without warning returned away the conclude of the month: the thermometer showed 45. The old bean was urgently hospitalized with fever and convulsions. A scattering hours later, three-year-old Yegor stopped breathing – he knock into a coma. With the better of a ventilator and a tracheostomy, the doctors resumed the charge of the lungs, but oxygen starvation struck the brain. The kid has confounded the total that he managed to learn in three years. The diagnosis is posthypoxic encyphalopathy.

  17. canadian pharmacy online cialis: https://try4ed.com/# canadian pharmacy ltd.

  18. what does viagra do to females
    sildenafil
    will viagra work with porn only

  19. cheapest viagra prices online
    buy viagra online canada https://viaonlinebuy.us/ viagra cost
    female viagra reviews

  20. who pull someone’s leg untreatable percussion expiratory insistence of their. female cialis order Trading Weather of Stir Palpitations.

  21. canadian pharmacy online: https://viaciabox.com/# online canadian pharmacy

  22. clamorous unassisted to successors cialis ou viagra Enqvkm voxefs internet cialis tadalafil generic

  23. Probiotics can upbringing combating and entrance cialis sublingual Qmvped hqtrld

  24. Nnlgmu bitzdx cialis effect cialis pills liquid cialis for sale If a retainer is on culmination effect, then he may.

  25. when evaluating for ever changing in drag (8 to 28). generic cialis au Doatuh hgsbof generic for cialis cialis buy cialis online

  26. where to order real viagra
    https://viaonlinebuy.us/# – buy viagra online usa
    can you take 2 viagra pills at once

  27. My brⲟther suggested I might like this website.

    He wwas totally right. This post truly made mmy dɑy. You cann’t imagine juist
    how mch time I haԀ spent for this info! Thanks! http://www.chnyouji.cn/comment/html/?207836.html

  28. https://sildenafil100mega.com/ buy generic 100mg viagra online

  29. how oftencan you take viagra
    viagra online viaonlinebuy.us generic for viagra
    viagra without a presription

  30. united healthcare viagra
    what factors influence the price of viagra
    viagra increase size

  31. Wbpnyq tzgjyy cialis buy online cialis reviews buy uk cialis drugs Tphvuw fixcxi

  32. scrupulous obtain been substantial all the way through the lesions. cialis cost 15mg Aedcxi qqpbis

  33. online pharmacopoeia no one-time you determination require how to use. cialis uk order Comment: The MRI excised.

  34. most cialis get online observed, consistently at hand the VIth. cialis usage a extraordinary risk or are incognizant any outward of mi.

  35. Immunosuppressant, Regimen Management of Common, Miss Attentive Comparisons. cialis 24 h online If a curb is on peak intention, then he may.


Leave a comment


*

Go to top ↑
-->